So it is with AngelouEconomics and its
recommendations for Lincoln to achieve the kind of economic growth
that will give it what amounts to a full-employment economy, more
and better-paying jobs, enough to go around and to attract other
job-creating businesses.
There are believers such as Jim Fram, president of the Lincoln
Chamber of Commerce and the Lincoln Partnership for Economic
Development, who is committed to AngelouEconomics' recommendations
for the city of Lincoln -- and wants you to be.
"People in this community want success," Fram said. "They haven't
all gone the same direction to get there. But this will get us on
the same team."
And there are skeptics such as David Hogberg, a researcher at the
Public Interest Institute, a Mount Pleasant, Iowa, research
organization that likes the idea of free markets and limited
government.
"The notion there's really a link between state economic
development spending or local economic development spending and
economic growth is pretty weak,"Hogberg said. "The most you can find
is some spending on infrastructure does have some positive impact,
but that would be expected.
"But when you get into targeting industries, giving them funds or
that kind of thing, the connection is tenuous at best.
"Basically, what you've got going is
that government is trying to favor an industry over another. It sort
of puts government in the position of picking economic winners and
losers and basically trying to make investment decisions."
So how does a Lincoln resident decide whether this study by
AngelouEconomics is worth the $100,000 the Lincoln Partnership for
Economic Development paid for it? Or the paper it's printed on?
How do people in Lincoln decide whether it's worth their trouble
and time to make the commitment the report asks for?
"That's, well, that's the $66 million question," said Angelos
Angelou, principal of AngelouEconomics and one of the principals
behind the emergence of Austin, Texas, into a bastion of new
economic prosperity. "I think Lincoln has to basically trust, first,
Lincoln. And people in Lincoln have to trust themselves for making
the right decisions.
"It's not about asking for trust in this report. We're not asking
anyone to take this for granted. Any economic development strategy
should be a dynamic process. Any good ideas should be in the plan.
This is not a static document.
"The thing we've talked about over and over again is information
does not flow very well in lincoln. People don't know a whole lot of
the basic elements of the city. They are probably their own worst
promoters of Lincoln. Being excited and energetic and the level of
enthusiasm, that is all about economic development.
"People are going to have to trust one another better, trust that
there is a need for one single economic development organization,
and it must be held accountable. That organization (LPED, in the
recommendations) makes the determinations on who are going to be its
partners. Those include the city, county, Lincoln Electric System,
Downtown Lincoln Association, Lincoln Independent Business
Association, a variety of other concerns, (and) first and foremost,
the colleges and universities."
Lincoln's economic development coordinator, Darl Naumann, the guy
the city pays to keep an eye on these things, falls into the
believer camp with Fram.
"If you tried to get any kind of structure on paper, you'd come
up with something like LPED," Naumann said. "It's just the logical
way to go. It has to be a public-private partnership." LPED's
partners now are the city and private business investors. Fram is
proposing to broaden its base. To lower the minimum investment and
to raise the maximum.
Angelou said his organization was not so much about prescribing a
plan, as about getting the community to feel excited and getting
behind the process of creating it.
"There are a whole lot of good plans that never see the light,"
Angelou said. "I'll be the first one to say implement our plan, or
implement HDR's." Last year, the Mayor's Technology Council
commissioned HDR Management Consulting, which produced a plan for
high-technology industrial growth.
"The focus ought to be on implementing the plan, not just talking
about it,"Angelou said. "From day one we focused on the process to
rally community support for politicians, the Chamber (of Commerce)
and the business community at large to make sure this initiative has
some life to it."
If it shows life, he said, it is because AngelouEconomics went
out of its way in its assessment phase to conduct more focus groups,
to interview more people one on one. "In all our visits, close to
400 people,"he said. "And I think the survey was completed by nearly
900."
Then AE talked to every City Council member, enlisted their
support, listened to them and university officials, Angelou said.
This morning, as Angelou presents its report in a sold-out event
at The Cornhusker, the purpose is to rally even more community
support, Angelou said.
"We are also suggesting Lincoln needs to tell its story to its
own citizens in an internal communications program," Angelou said.
To that end, Fram has pledged "lots of communication."
One day last week, Fram said he had spoken to two civic groups on
the study, two the week before, the League of Women Voters that day.
"What we want to do is not a secret, and we'll make sure people
know what we're doing," he said. "Believe me, there will be some
skeptics. When we're successful, and we will be, there will be some
who still say we didn't do it right."
This self sale, this prescription to look within the people of
Lincoln, rather than without, for answers to the city's perceived
economic uncertainty, accommodates the beliefs of another local, W.
Don Nelson. Nelson has spent years on either side of the divide
between private and public sectors, as a community and regional
planner, investment banker, government staff leader.
He hadn't read the AngelouEconomics report, but he read the
Sunday Journal Star's description of it.
Although comfortable and experienced with systematic studies of
public-policy issues, he's predisposed to skepticism.
"I've found that these studies run the risk of paying someone to
borrow your watch and tell you what time it is," he said.
But he's also inclined to endorse the idea that the people of
Lincoln are in the best position to help themselves.
"I've had two opportunities to move to Lincoln, and I took both
of them,"Nelson said. "And now Ihave two adult daughters who are
businesswomen and proud to be part of the local economy.
"If this thing stimulates people to look inside and say, `What
can we be doing?' then it will have paid for itself," Nelson said.
"But if it stimulates people to fly around the country looking
for some white knight, it will fall short. We should never lose
sight of the fact that we are the people in charge of our destiny."
Reach Dick Piersol at 473-7241 or dpiersol@journalstar.com.